The Ultimate Guide to Finding the Most Affordable and Secure Communities in America

2026-02-19 05:02:39

Finding a place to live that combines low costs with strong safety records has become increasingly challenging in today’s real estate market. However, a comprehensive analysis by GOBankingRates has identified 15 communities across the United States where residents can achieve both financial stability and peace of mind. These cheapest and safest places to live represent the sweet spot for families, retirees, and individuals seeking value without compromising on security.

What Makes These Communities Stand Out?

GOBankingRates evaluated numerous factors to compile this list of the most affordable and secure communities. The analysis examined data from the FBI’s Quarterly Crime Statistics, U.S. Census Bureau records, Zillow home valuations, and the Bureau of Labor Statistics. By identifying the safest 150 cities with populations exceeding 10,000 and then sorting them by total annual cost of living, the research team created a unique ranking that captures communities where both economic accessibility and security thrive.

The violent crime and property crime rates were pulled directly from FBI quarterly crime statistics, ensuring that the “safe” designation reflects actual law enforcement data rather than perception. Meanwhile, the total cost of living calculation encompasses housing, utilities, transportation, food, and healthcare expenses, giving a realistic picture of what it truly costs to live in each community.

Why Ohio Dominates the List

One striking finding is that Ohio accounts for seven of the top 15 positions—more than any other state. This concentration reflects the state’s favorable combination of affordable housing markets, reasonable living expenses, and well-established community safety programs. Cities like New Philadelphia, Parma Heights, Berea, Mount Vernon, Hamilton, Brunswick, and North Ridgeville all deliver solid livability scores while keeping total annual expenses well below $45,000.

This phenomenon demonstrates that achieving both affordability and safety is geographically possible, though it often requires looking beyond major metropolitan centers to smaller, established communities that have maintained stable economies and strong neighborhood cohesion.

Top-Tier Communities: Where Affordability Meets Peace of Mind

The rankings reveal several standout leaders in the cheapest and safest places to live category:

New Philadelphia, Ohio leads the pack with the lowest total annual cost of living at $35,549. Residents enjoy a modest home value of $186,258 with monthly mortgage costs around $1,101. The violent crime rate sits at just 0.69 per 1,000 residents, reflecting a genuinely secure environment.

New Ulm, Minnesota follows closely with an annual living cost of $36,361 and an exceptionally low violent crime rate of 0.29 per 1,000—among the safest figures in the entire ranking. Though home values are slightly higher at $222,693, the overall combination remains highly attractive.

San Elizario, Texas offers perhaps the lowest violent crime rate at just 0.10 per 1,000 residents, with total living costs of $36,738 annually. This small community demonstrates that exceptional safety and affordability can coexist even in less-populated areas.

Complete Community Rankings and Data Snapshot

The analysis encompasses 15 communities with detailed metrics for each:

Rank	City, State	Population	Annual Cost	Home Value	Crime Rate (Violent)
1	New Philadelphia, OH	17,563	$35,549	$186,258	0.69
2	New Ulm, MN	14,066	$36,361	$222,693	0.29
3	Parma Heights, OH	20,616	$36,575	$196,742	0.39
4	San Elizario, TX	10,123	$36,738	$167,333	0.10
5	Yorktown, IN	11,617	$37,332	$218,330	0.42
6	Berea, OH	18,330	$37,768	$220,573	0.60
7	Mount Vernon, OH	16,802	$37,928	$225,575	0.42
8	Columbus, IN	51,104	$40,402	$261,995	0.19
9	Butler, PA	13,306	$40,446	$229,211	0.20
10	Trenton, MI	18,242	$41,641	$231,232	0.33
11	Hamilton, OH	63,124	$42,726	$279,890	0.39
12	Orono, ME	10,699	$44,036	$295,752	0.18
13	Brunswick, OH	35,284	$44,251	$300,042	0.48
14	North Ridgeville, OH	36,043	$44,415	$313,398	0.56
15	Edwardsville, IL	26,543	$45,323	$302,677	0.30

What the Data Reveals About Your Housing Search

These 15 communities collectively demonstrate that sacrificing safety for affordability—or vice versa—is unnecessary. Each location provides violence crime rates well below national averages, property crime metrics that residents can trust, and annual living expenses that remain manageable for working families and fixed-income households.

The data encompasses multiple regions across the Midwest, South, and Northeast, suggesting that budget-friendly and secure living options exist nationwide. Whether you prioritize maximum affordability (below $36,500 annually) or seek larger communities with more amenities, this ranking of the cheapest and safest places to live offers verified options backed by federal crime statistics and official housing market data.

Making Your Decision: Research-Backed Insights

Based on 2025 market data, this analysis provides a reliable foundation for your relocation decision. Each figure represents actual home valuations, verified crime statistics from law enforcement, and comprehensive living expense calculations—not projections or estimates.

For anyone seeking communities where both financial prudence and personal security can thrive, this curated selection of 15 locations across America offers concrete, data-supported alternatives to expensive urban centers or unsafe neighborhoods. The combination of low housing costs, affordable overall living expenses, and strong security metrics makes these communities compelling options for your next move.

This page may contain third-party content, which is provided for information purposes only (not representations/warranties) and should not be considered as an endorsement of its views by Gate, nor as financial or professional advice. See Disclaimer for details.

1 Likes